Difference between revisions of "Talk:REGLTS"

Latest revision as of 03:00, 26 August 2009

Drafted by SNPWG7

Submitted to Hydro register manager Date Submitted to Nav register manager Date

two new attributes were proposed, both are placed at an appropriate place now

CATRXN becomes an own entry at the SNPWG FDD page

RXNCOD becomes an own entry at the SNPWG FDD page

raphael 03:00, 26 August 2009 (UTC): Just a note to mention that while John P. and I were working on the pilotage generic example we encountered regulations about pilot qualifications in the context of regulations often enough that we thought it worth considerng whether attribute PLTQFC should be bound to REGLTS. SNPWG is invited to consider this suggestion.

Difference between revisions of "Talk:REGLTS"

Latest revision as of 03:00, 26 August 2009

Navigation menu

Search

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 Submitted  to Nav register manager	Date
-== Proposed attribute CATRXN ==
+two new attributes were proposed, both are placed at an appropriate place now
-[[User:Rmm|raphael]] 05:23, 17 August 2009 (UTC) : A new attribute Category of regulation / restriction / recommendation is proposed. CATRXN (Category of regulation/restriction/recommendation) is a means of categorizing regulations, restrictions, and recommendations by sailing directions topic.  Categories include pilotage, traffic, anchorages, etc. Applications would use CATRXN values when they need to collect objects of a class - for example, when they collect all information objects for a specified place that pertain to pilotage, perhaps to display a box with "all pilotage information for place X" on the screen.
+[[CATRXN]] becomes an own entry at the SNPWG FDD page
-Specification (has evolved since the draft pilotage specification)
+[[RXNCOD]] becomes an own entry at the SNPWG FDD page
-Attribute: Category of regulation / restriction / recommendation
+[[User:Rmm|raphael]] 03:00, 26 August 2009 (UTC): Just a note to mention that while John P. and I were working on the pilotage generic example we encountered regulations about pilot qualifications in the context of regulations often enough that we thought it worth considerng whether attribute [[PLTQFC]] should be bound to [[REGLTS]].  SNPWG is invited to consider this suggestion.
-Acronym: CATRXN
-Attribute type: Simple
-Camel Case: categoryOfRxN
-Data Type: Enumeration
-Definition: The broad category or semantic group to which the information, regulation, restriction, or recommendation pertains.  These broad categories may correspond to subdivision titles in sailing directions.
-Values
-ID Meaning
-	pilotage
-	traffic
-	Anchorage
-	port services
-	Environmental Protection
-	security and customs
-	Offshore and Coastal Activities
-	Ship Reporting
-	Other Reporting
-	hazards and obstructions
-	Natural Conditions
-	signalling and ship-to-ship communications
-	small craft operations
-	cargo operations
-	aids to navigation
-	Miscellaneous Safety
-	Restrictions
-	danger zones and restricted area regulations
-	port facilities
-Definitions
-pilotage
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to pilotage
-traffic
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to traffic separation, recommended routes, and navigation and collision avoidance, for example, overtaking and head-on situations, navigation in fairways or channels, COLREGS
-Anchorage
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to use of anchorages
-port services
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to requirements and permissions for the use of port services
-Environmental Protection
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to nature reserves, protected species, environmental protection and pollution
-security and customs
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to security and customs
-Offshore and Coastal Activities
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to offshore and coastal activities dangerous to shipping such as drilling platforms, military exercises, dumping grounds
-Ship Reporting
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to required filings and reports for VTS and ship reporting systems
-Other Reporting
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to required filings and reports other than VTS and ship reporting systems
-hazards and obstructions
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to hazards and obstructions
-Natural Conditions
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to operation of vessels in severe weather or other special meteorological conditions
-signalling and ship-to-ship communications
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to signalling and ship-to-ship communications
-small craft operations
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to small craft operations
-cargo operations
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to commercial cargo operations
-aids to navigation
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to aids to navigation
-Miscellaneous Safety
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to miscellaneous port and waterways safety
-Restrictions
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to regulated navigation areas and limited access areas
-danger zones and restricted area regulations
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to danger zones and restricted area regulations danger zones and restricted area regulations
-port facilities
-Regulation/restriction/recommendation pertaining to requirements and permissions for the use of port services
-References: M-3 Chapters C 2.2, C 2.8; BSH new-format Sailing Directions; US Coast Pilot Chapter 2, Navigation Regulations (multiple volumes)
-== Proposed Attribute RXNCOD ==
-[[User:Rmm|raphael]] 05:35, 17 August 2009 (UTC): RXNCOD (Regulation/restriction/regulation code) is intended to provide numeric codes that identify the information as one of the most common types of regulations (or restrictions, etc.) RXNCOD values are precise enough for an application to display specific alerts. RXNCOD values may correspond to specific text ("e.g., pilotage compulsory"). Applications could use RXNCOD to display specific strings, or provide and handle specific alerts.
-Attribute: Regulation / restriction / recommendation code
-Acronym: RXNCOD
-Attribute type: Simple
-Camel Case: rxnCode
-Data Type: Enumeration
-Definition: This attribute encodes the most common types of regulations (recommendations, restrictions).
-Values:
-	Pilotage compulsory
-	Pilot qualifications
-	Passage prohibited
-	Passage conditionally prohibited
-	Overtaking prohibited
-	Overtaking conditionally permitted
-	Restricted passage
-	Tugs
-	Quarantine and health
-	Customs
-	Loading and unloading
-	Drawbridge operations
-	Navigation prohibited
-	Right of way
-	Traffic permission required
-	Dimensional
-Definitions:
-Pilotage compulsory
-Pilotage is compulsory
-Pilot qualifications
-Pertaining to the qualifications of pilot (details described in INFORM attribute or TXTDSC file)
-Passage prohibited
-Passage prohibited at all times
-Passage conditionally prohibited
-Passage prohibited under certain weather conditions (details in INFORM or TXTDSC file)
-Overtaking prohibited
-Overtaking prohibited at all times
-Overtaking conditionally permitted
-Overtaking permitted only under certain conditions (stated in INFORM/TXTDSC file)
-Restricted passage
-Pertaining to head-on situations in restricted passages or fairways (details in INFORM or TXTDSC file)
-Tugs
-Tug assistance compulsory
-Quarantine and health
-Quarantine and health regulations (details described in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Customs
-Customs regulations (details described in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Loading and unloading
-Loading and unloading cargo (details in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Drawbridge operations
-Drawbridge operations (details in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Navigation prohibited
-Navigation prohibited
-Right of way
-Pertaining to right of way (details in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Traffic permission required
-Permission required from an authority for transit (details in INFORM or TXTDSC)
-Dimensional
-Applicable only to vessels exceeding specified dimensions (associated chalim will specify limits)
-Remarks: This attribute encodes the most common types of regulations (recommendations, restrictions) in a form that software (e.g., ECDIS) can use to do at least some subject-specific processing. Since the details are in natural language (i.e., as text in INFORM), this will not be comprehensive, but (a) it should be possible to use this in conjunction with “chalim” in some cases to provide enhancements like automatic indicators in the ECDIS/ECS that passage is forbidden for vessels of certain size; (b) provide hints, such as a hint that pilotage is probably compulsory, etc.
-In spite of the similarity in names, they are actually have different functions: CATRXN is intended for "classifying" of 4-brothers instances; RXNCOD is designed to "identify" what the specific regulation, etc., says in a way that can be recognized by software, which allows specific alerts to be raised.
-Comments for addition of more codes, refinement or removal of codes9, 10, 11, 12, 14 invited.